Back to top

Image: Bigstock

Marathon Petroleum vs. Par Pacific: Picking the Better Refining Play

Read MoreHide Full Article

Key Takeaways

  • Par Pacific is the better refining pick, despite Marathon Petroleum's edge in scale and shareholder returns.
  • Par Pacific trades at 0.38X forward sales against Marathon Petroleum's 0.82X, highlighting its valuation edge.
  • Par Pacific's Hawaii Renewables turned profitable in Q3 2026, while the company achieved a net cash position.

Marathon Petroleum Corporation (MPC - Free Report) and Par Pacific Holdings, Inc. (PARR - Free Report) offer contrasting investment opportunities in the U.S. refining industry as favorable refining margins support downstream profitability. MPC operates an extensive refining and marketing network, complemented by midstream operations through MPLX and renewable diesel assets. The company is optimizing its portfolio through planned refinery divestitures and investments targeting higher-return opportunities, particularly along the Gulf Coast. Meanwhile, PARR maintains a smaller, geographically focused refining platform across Hawaii and the western United States, supported by integrated logistics, retail and expanding renewables operations. Both companies are capitalizing on a constructive refining environment while pursuing operational improvements and disciplined capital allocation. However, their differing operational scales, growth strategies and financial priorities warrant a closer comparison to determine which stock offers better investment potential.

The Case for Marathon Petroleum Stock

Marathon Petroleum benefits from its extensive refining network, integrated operations and strong cash generation capabilities. Its refining and marketing business recorded adjusted EBITDA of $9.9 billion in the third quarter of 2026, supported by stronger refining margins and 100% crude capacity utilization. Additionally, its midstream operations through MPLX provide a relatively stable earnings stream, complementing the cyclical refining business and strengthening MPC’s overall financial flexibility.

MPC’s strategic investments offer meaningful opportunities for long-term profitability. The company is advancing refinery optimization projects at Galveston Bay and Garyville, targeting higher distillate production, improved feedstock flexibility and increased throughput by year-end 2027. Its planned divestiture of the St. Paul Park and Mandan refineries, with MPC receiving $3.45 billion excluding inventory, is expected to unlock capital for higher-return investments, primarily along the Gulf Coast. These initiatives should strengthen its refining competitiveness and margin capture capabilities.

MPC’s robust financial position further supports its investment appeal. The company returned $3.3 billion to its shareholders during the third quarter and announced a 10% quarterly dividend increase. Meanwhile, MPLX’s growing distributions are expected to provide MPC with approximately $3.1 billion annually, supporting capital investments and shareholder distributions. The company's substantial liquidity and expanded share repurchase authorization provide additional capital allocation flexibility.

However, MPC remains exposed to volatility in refining margins, crude oil differentials and operating expenses. A normalization of elevated crack spreads may pressure profitability, while planned refinery upgrades involve execution risks and capital requirements. Additionally, the proposed refinery divestiture remains subject to regulatory approvals and closing conditions, creating uncertainty regarding its completion and anticipated benefits.

The Case for Par Pacific Stock

Par Pacific benefits from its strategically located refining operations across Hawaii and the western United States, supported by integrated logistics and retail businesses. Its refining segment generated adjusted EBITDA of $618 million in the third quarter of 2026, reflecting favorable refining margins and operational execution. Although the results included $222 million in small refinery exemption benefits, the company's mainland refineries demonstrated strong operating performance, highlighting the earnings potential of its geographically focused refining network.

PARR’s operational improvements offer opportunities for sustainable margin enhancement. The company successfully completed its Hawaii refinery turnaround, positioning the facility for improved reliability and a five-year operating cycle. Meanwhile, its Billings refinery in Montana has benefited from efficiency initiatives, with year-to-date throughput increasing to approximately 56,000 barrels per day and production costs declining below $10 per barrel. Further high-return growth projects and logistics improvements are expected to strengthen the facility’s earnings potential.

PARR is also expanding its opportunities in renewable fuels. Its Hawaii Renewables business achieved its first profitable quarter in the third quarter of 2026, supported by improving production and feedstock flexibility. The facility successfully processed canola, yellow grease and tallow, demonstrating its ability to diversify feedstock sourcing. Continued optimization of its renewable diesel operations should support profitability and provide an additional avenue for earnings growth.

Furthermore, PARR’s strengthening balance sheet enhances its financial flexibility. The company ended September 2026 with approximately $2.4 billion in liquidity and achieved a net cash position. Its planned divestiture of the Laramie Energy interest is expected to generate approximately $120 million in initial proceeds, providing additional resources for high-return projects and opportunistic share repurchases.

Price Performance Comparison

Since the beginning of the year, shares of MPC and PARR have surged 154.9% and 108%, respectively.

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

Valuation Comparison

From a valuation perspective — in terms of forward price-to-sales ratio — Par Pacific is trading at a discount of 0.38X compared with Marathon Petroleum’s 0.82X.

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

EPS Estimates

According to the Zacks Consensus Estimate, MPC’s earnings are set to rise 519.7% year over year in 2026.

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

The same for PARR’s 2026 EPS indicates a year-over-year increase of 275.1%.

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

Summing Up

Both Marathon Petroleum and Par Pacific stand to benefit from favorable refining margins, operational improvements and disciplined capital allocation.

Marathon Petroleum holds an edge in refining scale, integrated midstream operations and shareholder returns. Moreover, its Gulf Coast refinery upgrades and portfolio optimization initiatives offer long-term growth opportunities, supporting its Zacks Rank #3 (Hold).

However, Par Pacific emerges as the better investment choice, driven by its discounted valuation, improving refinery efficiency, renewable diesel expansion and strengthening balance sheet, which enhances its investment appeal. These advantages position PARR favorably for future profitability and earnings growth, justifying its Zacks Rank #1 (Strong Buy).

You can see the complete list of today’s Zacks #1 Rank stocks here.

Published in